Topper Copies

5) Culture is unique to human beings. Do you agree? Present arguments in favour and against the statement. (15 marks)

Zufishan Haque, AIR 34, 2023

E.B. Tylor states that culture is that integral whole which encompasses laws, morals, customs, art, beliefs and all other habits and capabilities acquired by man as a member of society.

A.L. Kroeber states that culture is the adaptation of man to the environment.

Thus, anthropologists have stated in definitions that culture is associated with man, and hence is unique to human beings.

Arguments in favour 1. Culture is universally found among humans. Culture of Inuit Eskimos to culture of Bushmen in Africa. 2. Culture has existed among humans since the beginning. Culture of Indus Valley to modern urban culture. 3. Biologically, human evolution favoured culture among humans.

Arguments against 1. Cultural activities are also seen in other animals. Eg. termite fishing in chimps, use of tools by primates, washing sweet potato by macaques. These activities are transmitted to their offspring.

However, cultural activities in other animals are instinct-based. Cognitive development is not to an extent that they can interpret; they can only communicate through fixed symbols.

A.L. Kroeber's Ant Experiment A.L. Kroeber demonstrated that even if an ant is in isolation, it performs its role assigned as per the division of labour in ant society. However, humans isolated at birth and later merged with a new society do not exhibit the cultural traits of the society they were born in. Hence, in animals culture is instinct-based.