Topper Copies

Que.5 (b) सामूहिक सुरक्षा की मूल अवधारणाएँ क्या हैं तथा इसकी सफलता के लिए आवश्यक पूर्वापेक्षाएँ क्या हैं? (10 अंक) What are the basic assumptions of collective security and discuss prerequisites for the success of collective security?

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

Collective security is a Liberal-idealist alternative to Balance of power of realist which emerged after World Wars. It meant security is indivisible. Thus attack against one is seen as attack against all.

As per Morgenthau, collective security is based on following assumptions :-

1) Equal distribution of power in world i.e there should not be preponderant/ hegemonic power.

2) Countries must be willing to subsume their self interests under collective/ shared interests.

3) Agreement among states on aggressor and willingness to spend resources to counter it.

The success of collective security requires many prerequisites. As per Organzki, there should be a international organisation which can effective coordi -nate action against aggressor. Secondly, combined strength of countries must be greater than aggressor.

However, collective security based on United Nations has been a failure. Realist argue that nation would pursue self interest over collective interest and focus on relative gains. U.N mostly faces legitimacy crisis and conflict among P5.

Instead of collective security, new models like deterrence (Bernard Brodie) and collective defence (of NATO) are seen as better guarantee of security.