Que.3(b) पार्टी प्रणालियों को आकार देने में चुनावी प्रणालियों और सामाजिक विभाजनों (cleavages) के प्रभाव को स्पष्ट कीजिए। (15 अंक) Explain the impact of electoral systems and cleavages in shaping party systems.
Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025
Party system is not shaped by number of parties but number of parties having systemic relevance' - G. Sartori.
Party system refers to changes in the electoral composition of parties in a system. i.e rise and fall of parties.
Party system can be understood either from electoral systems or from cleavages perspective.
From electoral systems view, Behavioural scholar like (Duverger) has given Duverger law. As per this, if there is a majoritarian electoral system like first past the post, it will result in bipolar system. The prime examples are UK (Labour & Conservative party) and USA (Republican & democratic party)
However, if there is Proportional system & single transfereble vote, list system etc, it will result in multi party system. This is evident in France (alternative voting system).
India is an exception to duverger law since it has multiple parties despite having first past the post system.
Second, Cleavages which are divisions based on caste, class, religion etc. can shape a party system. cleavage theory is given by Rokkan & Lipset, as per this party system in Europe is frozen on basis of cleavages of 20th Century Europe. (Freezing hypothesis). They highlight 4 primary cleavages:
1. Rural - urban - rise of agrarian parties 2. Labour - capital - workers parties 3. Core - periphery - rise of minority/ ethnic parties 4. state - church - rise of secular and conservative parties.
Social cleavage theory explains emergence of multi party system in India based on caste (SP, BSP), class (CPI) and periphery (AGP, DMK).
Thus party systems are influenced by both electoral systems and social cleavages.