Topper Copies

Que.3(a) यथार्थवाद (Realism) के प्रमुख सैद्धान्तिक प्रस्थापनाओं पर चर्चा कीजिए। क्या समकालीन विश्व को समझने में यथार्थवाद आज भी प्रासंगिक है? (20 अंक) Discuss the core theoretical assumptions of Realism. Does realism remain relevant in understanding and explaining the contemporary world?

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

Realism is a hegemonic school in International relations. There is not one but many realism.

Two main assumption of Realism as per Donnelly is :-

1) Human nature is selfish - this guides state behaviour.

2) International system is anarchic due to absence of a world government.

Based on these assumptions emerged classical realism and Neo realism. Classical realism is works of Hans Morgenthau emphasise on human nature a power seeking for state's power- maxumisation behaviour.

whereas Structuralism realism (kenneth Waltz) gives structural analysis i.e blames international anarchy for state's power seeking behaviour,

Another key assumption is that states are rational actors. They work on cost-benefit analysis guided by self-interest to decide its action.

In action, State can either go for defense or offense. Defensive realist like Kenneth Waltz believe state is security maximiser where offensive realist like Mearsheimer believe state is power maximiser i.e hegemony quest is natural.

Realism was challenged by idealism/ Liberalism specially since end of cold war. Realist could not explain the end of Cold war. Similarly, they could not explain the phenomenon of globalisation which was explained by scholars of complex-interdependence (Keohane & Nye).

Realist also failed to account for rise of non-State actors since realist take a State centric view. They could not explain behaviour of MNC. (can be explained by Thomas Friedman golden arches). Neither they could explain role of terrorist organisation (Eg 9/11 attack).

All these factors led to questions over relevance of realism. However, Today as we see rise of China and Cold War 2.0 playing out between USA & China, Realism has assumed significance. Despite Complex interdependence, these nations are engaged in competition which could only be explained through realist lens of 'power maximisation'

Similarly - we are seeing legitimacy crisis in global institutions like. WB, UN, IMF. Realist have always called it 'great delusion' of liberals ([?]). The realist prescription of Balance of power is playing out in Indo-Pacific (eg Quad).

Thus Realism remains a hegemonic school to understand the current geopolitical flux -