Topper Copies

(a) What are the two main schools in economic anthropology? What are the fundamental differences in their approach to the study of economic systems in simple societies? (20 marks)

Zufishan Haque, AIR 34, 2023

Economic Anthropology is the study of human economic behaviour in its widest cultural, geographical scope.

Schools in Economic Anthropology Karl Polanyi, in his work "The Great Transformation", first talked about the difference between western industrialised and tribal societies, leading to two schools in economic anthropology.

1. Formalist school It views humans as economically rational individuals. The formal school analyses the logical decision making to allocate scarce resources to fulfill unlimited wants of the members of society. Proponents: Raymond Firth, Harold Schneider

2. Substantivist school It opines that principles of neo-classical economics cannot be applied to study primitive societies. It tries to understand economic behaviour by linking it to the cultural premises and socio-cultural institutions. Proponents: Karl Polanyi, Marshall Sahlins

Differences between Formalists and Substantivists

| Formalists | Substantivists | |---|---| | Principles of neo-classical economics can be applied to study primitive societies | Principles of neo-classical economics cannot be applied | | Society is made up of independently acting economically rational individuals | Society is systems-oriented and the individual alone cannot determine economic decisions | | It focuses on profit-maximisation | It does not believe in the concept of profit-making in simple society |

Eg. In simple societies, if not maximisation of money-goals, they seek to maximise reputation or leisure-time.

Case study: Kula Trade Malinowski studied reciprocity as an alternative to money economy to understand economic behaviour in primitive societies.

[a boxed diagram titled "Fig: Kula Trade" showing four islands connected by curved arrows, labelled Soulava and Mwali]

Soulava and Mwali are red shell made necklaces and bracelets that are exchanged between the island communities in Trobriand Island.

Substantivist view: Trobrianders engage in hazardous voyages to exchange the sea-shells which have no monetary value. This cannot be explained through the formalist view, as the aim is to maintain social order rather than make profit.

Formalist view: Unique sea-shells are with the chief, which maximises his satisfaction.

The formalist and substantivist debate is outdated with the integration of economies with the coming of globalisation.