Topper Copies

Que.1 (d) पूँजीवादी और समाजवादी अर्थव्यवस्थाओं में राज्य की विशेषताओं की तुलना कीजिए। (10 अंक) Compare the characteristics of the State in capitalist and socialist economies.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

'Political science begins and ends with the state' - Garner

State has been a core area of research in comparative politics. scholars have compared the nature of state in capitalist & socialist economies. In capitalist economics, there has been a transition from laissez faire to welfarist + Neoliberal state. Overall state has played the role of 'nightwatchmen' to ensure freedom/safety & property.

In contrast, socialist economies have seen welfarist state based on socio-economic rights. The focus is on redistribution of wealth instead of political freedom, which is seen as bourgeois concept.

If capitalist states are democratic, As socialist economies have seen rise of authoritarian states (eg Russia & China), capitalist states are based on pluralist model of democracy (Robert Dahl) where multiple group dominates, socialist states are primarily based on single party dominance (eg PCC in China).

Despite these differences, elitist theory scholars held that power in both capitalist and socialist states are in hand of power elites (iron law of oligarchy - Robert Michels).

Today, these states are in a state of transition, we see rise of authoritarianism in capitalist states like USA and move towards neo-liberal model in socialist states like India.