Topper Copies

Q.8) (a) Everything has turned out to be at least somewhat heritable (passed down), yet nothing has turned out to be absolutely heritable. Explain the statement in context of nature-nurture debate in Anthropology. (20 marks) (b) Chromosomal aberrations can play havoc with human body and mind. Explain with suitable examples. (15 marks) (c) What are genetic markers and what is their usefulness? Why are blood groups considered as good genetic markers? Illustrate with examples. (15 marks)

Sachin Bg

a) Everything has turned out to be at least somewhat heritable (passed down), yet nothing has turned out to be absolutely heritable. Explain the statement in context of nature-nurture debate in Anthropology

Eric Turkheimer gave the above quotation that everything of one's trait or character is due to effect of both nature & nurture.

The statement reconciles the fact that both nature & nurture are working together and it never runs in confrontation with the other.

Nature - Nurture Debate

It is one of the central debates in Anthropology & other discipline. The debate arose in order to find whether nature is more important in human development or it is nurture (environment).

It is in other words the debate between the genetics of an individual & the environment in which he/she grows.

Various thinkers & their viewpoints

1. Nature extremists like F. Galton, Darwin, Huxley, etc took the side of nature saying that it is one's genes that is important in determining one's personality.

Eg: Blacks can never achieve the mental or cognitive ability like European counterparts - was alleged notion by them

2. Nurture extremists: various anthropological thinkers like F. Boas, Mead, Benedict, etc opposed Nature determinism & explored how nurture plays important role in determining character of individual.

Eg: Mead's study of sex & Temperament in 3 societies

3. Current Status of debate

The newer studies have discovered the relevance of argument of both sides. While it is seen that genes determine the direction one might take as an individual, it's nurture or environment which shall determine the extent of one's development, as without adequate support or care, no talent is manifested.

Case Studies

1. Eric Turkheimer's study of IQ inheritance: It studied twins who were reared apart and belonging to different classes of society. It found that IQ of twins in well nourished family depended on genetics, while IQ of person in impoverished families depended on Environment because inadequate support suppressed their IQ. 2. Alcoholism: It's found that although genetic predisposition exist for alcoholism, an individual won't turn alcoholic if not triggered by external factors, like stress, trauma, etc 3. New age diseases: Various diseases like diabetes, hypertension, cardiac attack, etc are now considered multifactorial in that both genetic & environment are causative agents.

Therefore, the debate is outdated & it's now a wisdom that both genetic & environment are important for human development.

b) Chromosomal aberrations can play havoc with human body and mind. Explain with suitable examples

Chromosomal aberration refers to change in structure or number of chromosomes present in human body leading to chromosomal disorders.

Play havoc

Genes are basis of inheritance & functional unit of DNA. Chromosomes made up of genes are crucial for inheritance of several important character, and their absence or aberration causes disorders that affect both physical & mental development.

Consider example of

Turner's syndrome

It is also referred to as monosomy of X chromosome in females Genotype: 45 XO The absence of X chromosome in female leads to poor development of female reproductive organ, like underdeveloped breast, genitalia, short stature, microcephaly, regression of intellectual development, etc.

Down's syndrome

It is referred to as trisomy of 21st chromosome. Genotype: 47 XX/47 XY

The Down's syndrome children suffer from microcephaly/poor development of brain, epicanthic fold/mongoloid feature, autism, poor cognitive abilities, etc

Klinefelter's syndrome

It is referred to as trisomy of X chromosome in male. Genotype: 47 XXY

They have features like gynecomastia (not breast system), poor male reproductive organ development, longer thigh, poor mental cognition, etc.

Therefore, there is need for genetic counselling & screening at birth to be made integral part of modern medicine, affordable to all.

c) What are genetic markers and what is their usefulness? Why are blood groups considered as good genetic markers? Illustrate with examples

Genetic markers refer to the particular sequence of genes or their expression whose presence or absence helps in differentiating different set of human population.

Therefore they act as 'markers' (identifying feature) of given population and also as 'marker' for human variation.

Significance of genetic markers 1. Genetic markers help in evolutionary studies. For example, Out of Africa theory is strongly supported by modern genetics as African population has most diverse set of genetic markers, capable of being parent population 2. Genetic markers useful in demographic studies in India, in determining the reproductive status of different population 3. Genetic markers crucial for medicine or medical anthropology: they help determine or diagnose various disease. Eg: Transferrin down => Anaemic condition 4. Nutritional anthropology: certain genetic markers determine the individual's capacity to consume & process certain food. Eg: Lactose intolerance

Blood groups considered as good marker

Blood group like ABO blood group system are considered 'good' because of following factors 1. They are of distinct categories, eg: A blood group -> +ve or -ve, B blood group -> +ve or -ve, etc 2. They are present in all human population 3. They don't change with time or space, i.e they remain constant in human wherever they are 4. They are easy to determine - doesn't need complex or sophisticated system 5. They are affordable & cheaper - can be used widespread by all countries.

Importance 1. They are used to study classification of Human population in international or intra-national manner 2. They are extensively used for diagnosis of various diseases, eg complications, fatalities, etc.

Therefore, Genetic markers have become integral to both individual level Human genetics & population genetics.