Topper Copies

Que.1 (b) उपनिवेशोत्तर देशों में असुरक्षा द्वंद्व (Insecurity Dilemma) की अवधारणा को स्पष्ट कीजिए (10 अंक) Explain the insecurity dilemma in post-colonial countries.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

Post-Colonial countries are those states which haven't came their colonial character. In word of F.W Riggs - Prismatic societies and in word of Gunnar Myrdal 'soft states'.

as per scholars like Barry Posen, realist frameworks like security dilemma given by John Herz don't apply to post-colonial societies. They suffer from insecurity dilemma.

Insecurity dilemma means post- colonial states suffer from intra state conflicts based on identities. ethnic groups mobilise to maximise their power, feeding the suspicion/mistrust among other communities.

For example, ethnic conflict in North East India between Kukis and Meiteis can be understood as insecurity dilemma.

There is a conflict for resources among communities leading to ethnic conflict-

insecurity dilemma helps us in understanding reversal of democracy in post colonial states as per Samuel P. Huntington. Since political modernisation could not keep pace with social economic Modernisation, it caused 'political decay'.

However, Marxist differ on this, They blame capitalism for creation of conflict in post-colonial states (A.G Frank- instrumentalist theory).

Thus, insecurity dilemma is a contested concept in international relations.