Topper Copies

The landmark verdict in State of Tamil Nadu vs Governor of Tamil Nadu (2025) once again laid bare the fundamental questions about India's federal structures, the limits of gubernatorial discretion, and the scope of the power of judicial review under the Constitution. Comment.

Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025

Art. 200 empowers the governor to exercise his discretion in reserving a bill for presidential reference which opens scope for a gridlock like situation at the state level.

In this respect, the SC heard the State of Tamil Nadu vs Governor case in 2025, The SC clearly noted that the governor's discretion shall be used in rare cases.

Moreover, the governor cannot delay the bill without responding as the constitution does not provide any pocket veto to the governor.

Also, once the bill is returned by the governor and passed again by the state legislature, the governor cannot reserve the bill for presidential reference under A.200.

The wide misuse of gubernatorial powers, not only in Tamil Nadu but also in west bengal shows the governor's use as an extended arm of centre with velvet gloves to paralyse the state government.

The turf strifes between state governments led by opposition parties and the governor backslides the federal spirit of Indian constitution.

The constitution does not bind the governor with the advice of state council of ministers. This provision is widely exploited by the governors. However, SC in Manipur assembly case and Maharashtra governor's case limited governor's discretion to rare cases of emergency.

The governor's position instead of being viewed as a central agent must be an independent constitutional body to act as a friend, philosopher and mentor for the state government.

Sarkaria Commission recommendations of appointed a politically detached figure as a governor, appointment from a list prepared by ISC and non appointment of a figure from the central party in case of different parties at the state and centre can ensure the independence of governor's office.

The governor as the executive head of state government. Its independence is sine qua non for the federal wheel of Indian democracy.