Topper Copies

While during the freedom movement, the Government of India Act 1935 had been reviled as a 'charter of slavery', now more than a third of the Constitution is borrowed from that hated law. What could have been the probable determining factors behind this paradox? Explain.

Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025

The Government of India act 1935 was based on the Simon commission report which saw widespread protests in 1927.

However, the present Indian constitution is a carbon copy of 1935 act as opined by KC wheare.

The office of governor has been borrowed from the act into A. 52. The centrally appointed officer has been a contested yet useful and inevitable element of parliamentary democracy at the state level.

Moreover, the emergency provisions under A. 352, 356 and 360 are the result of 1935 act.

Use of A.356 162 times in Indian post independence history reflects its colonial origins, and draconian effect.

Also, the three fold division of legislative powers in the seventh schedule has been borrowed from the act. The only difference is in the form of residuary powers which rested with governor general in the pre-independence era and now rest with the Indian parliament.

Similarly the office of Speaker has been borrowed from the same act reflecting British tradition in westminster model. The speaker however now is a symbol of freedom and dignity of the house instead of colonial legacy.

However, Indian constitution is a synthesis of best practices from around the globe with judicial supremacy from US constitution, federal structure from Canadian constitution, DSP from Irish constitution etc.

The high convergence of 1935 act and Indian constitution can be attributed to Indian experience with the British parliamentary system.

Moreover, Indian constitution is not a slavish imitation of 1935 act. The formation of 1935 act was a result of three round table conferences where Indians were a major chunk of representation.

Hence 1935 act already reflected core Indian demands through deliberations in the round table conferences.

As Gandhi ji notes about the Indian constitution, it is a document which kept windows open for fresh air from around the globe yet the doors closed to prevent it from being swept away.

Also Ambedkar justifies constitution's huge inferences from different sources as it was formed so late in history that all it could do was to mould already existing provisions for its own needs.