Despite the CEC's vital role in Indian democracy, the Supreme Court in Anoop Baranwal vs UOI (2023) highlighted that successive governments haven't institutionalised a transparent appointment process. Critically evaluate the changes made by the CEC & ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service & Term of Office) Act 2023 towards realising S.C. guidelines.
Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025
A.324 provided ECI with plenary powers to ensure free and fair elections in India. The 'CEC' playing a major part in India's democratic electoral process must be free of external interference.
In Anoop Baranwal vs UoI 2023, SC framed guidelines for fair appointment procedure of CEC devoid of executive dominance. A committee comprising PM, Leader of opposition and Chief justice of India shall form the collegium to appoint CEC.
However, the government responded with CEC' & ECs (Appointments, Conditions and Services) Act, 2023 which tweaked the proposed committee recommendations and established executive majority in the selection committee by replacing CJI with a centrally chosen cabinet minister.
The act prima facie falls to stand true to the very purpose of removing executive interference in appointment process of CEC and ECs. The [?] system of appointment shall continue which hinders the ECI's power to take strong electoral reforms.
Moreover, this system shall reduce ECI to a caged parrot of the executive which might take selective actions against the opposition parties on political pressure.
At the same time, criminalisation of politics shall continue to increase. In near future with [?] of MPs facing criminal charges already standing at 46%, due to lack of accountability of legislators and inability of ECI to take disciplinary actions.
However, the act has institutionalised the selection process which opens the appointment process to judicial scrutiny on the grounds of malafide.
Moreover, fixed term of CEC and ECs and seniority criteria shall prevent politically changed appointments.
India's democracy rests on the fairness of electoral process. Independence of ECI by applying Dinesh Goswami and Indrajit Gupta recommendations shall be a way forward to uphold India's status as a mother of democracy.