The Supreme Court of India was established more than 75 years ago as a core part of India's constitutional project. Do you think the court has been able to live up to the ideals of justice imagined by the framers of the Constitution? Give arguments in favour of your points, and substantiate them with empirical facts.
Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025
Supreme court of India has not been a mere spectator but an active participant of India's social revolution.
The constitution makers envisaged the SC to be a protector of social economic and political justice. Hence an independent judiciary with federal powers and responsibility to protect fundamental rights (A.13, 32) was enshrined in the SC's role.
Not only has SC lived upto its ideals but gone beyond its mandate to uphold the ideals of justice in Indian society.
It has created a harmonious construction between citizens' right and social justice as was evident in Menaka gandhi case. The court has also prioritised constitutional morality over social morality (Navtej Singh Johar case and Sabarimala case) to ensure not only procedural but also substantive social justice.
Balancing affirmative action with meritocracy has been a significant achievement by declaring the creamy layer criteria and 50% ceiling on reservation.
Not only social, but SC has also stood as a flagbearer of economic democracy as was seen in recent property association of India vs UoI case, 2024, where it co-harmonised the Right to property with right of eminent domain of the state providing for fair wealth redistribution.
Furthermore, the court's stance in MC Mehta case, Vellore citizen welfare case, Bhopal gas leak case and Ganga rejuvenation case has made it a sentinel on qui-vive of environmental justice.
Similarly, the court has upheld political justice by ensuring fairness of electoral process in Lily Thomas case, Abhiram Singh case and recently by nullifying electoral rolls in ADR vs. UoI, 2023.
Hence, It can be said that SC has lived upto its mandate of protecting ideals of justice, though at times it is accused of being passive (eg ADM Jabalpur case) and committed judiciary (eg. emergency of 1975)