Role played by the Supreme Court in reinventing the Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP).
Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025
The constituent assembly recorded heated debates on the inclusion of DPSP in the constitution because of their non justiciable and advisory nature.
KT shah calls DPSPs as a fraud on the promises made during Indian national movement. While KC Wheare calls them as disordered accommodation of diverse principles of national leaders.
However, SC has led to re-imagination of DPSPs role by using them for creative constitutional interpretation from time to time. The recent property welfare association vs UoI re-interpreted the phrase "property of common interest" to harmonise it with legal right to property.
Moreover, the social programs of government were protected from legal violability by interpreting them through the lens of DPSP. For instance, land reforms were upheld seeing them in concurrence with A. 39(b) and 39(c).
Similarly, SC devised doctrines like polluter pays principle and public trust doctrine in line with A.48A. In various cases, like Shayara Bano case, Sarla Mudgal case and Jose Paulo Coutinho case, SC has re-inforced the need of UCC.
& Minerva Mills case resulted in principle of harmonious construction hyphenating rights and duties of citizens in line with Gandhian idea of duty centricity.