Topper Copies

"The Indian state has always tried to delimit the aspirations of and energy for radical socio-economic changes through a fabricated consensus and accommodative politics." — Francine Frankel. Critically examine.

Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025

Indian accommodative politics limits the scope of radical changes by the government especially in the periods of non surplus coalitions.

Francine Frankel rightly identifies the problem of fabricated consensus in Indian polity. Diverging interests of political parties at the centre and accommodative stance of central government towards regional parties often leads to what Gunnar Myrdal refers to as soft state.

Revoking farm laws, delay in implementation of NEP, lack of pro-active approach towards interstate water dispute defers the executive from resolving these disputes, due to opposition from other parties.

2024 elections resulted in the formation of a non surplus government and strong opposition further leading to cold stances on the issues like market reforms, UCC, and Caste census.

However, in the past leaders of weak coalitions have taken strong steps due to personality factors. For Instance, PV Narsimha Rao's LPG reforms and look East policy shows charisma of accommodative politics with strong decision making power.

Similarly, Atal Bihari Vajpayee took radical steps like: Agra summit, Lahore summit, resumption of India-Pakistan bus service and Kargil war. His preparation of nuclear test further testifies has strong personality.

while the accomodative stance of UPA 1 and UPA 2 largely saw minimum governance stance, it successfully took radical decisions like signing civil nuclear deal, 2005 with USA.

Sudha Pai rightly notes, Indian multi party system results into shifting strategically between democratic accomodation and strong developmental politics. Even present NDA government has taken strong stance on sensitive issues like fishermen issue, Russia ukraine war and Operation Sindoor inspite of being a non surplus government.

Hence, though Indian politics mandates an accomodative stance for electoral pragmatism, political leaders have often defied this stereotype.