Do you agree with the view that unless the salutary role of the courts is in place, there is no guarantee that bureaucracy and corporations would rise to the occasion to protect the environment? Critically evaluate the role of the Supreme Court in the environmental movement in India.
Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025
The SC has expanded the scope of A.21 by liberally interpreting it as was also done in the recent Ranjitsinh vs UoI, 2024 pushing environmental constitutionalism.
SC began its journey of environmental jurisdiction in MC Mehta case series, declaring right to environment as an integral part of A.21. The court also devised public trust doctrine in the same case.
Moreover, the SC took to constructive innovation in Oleum gas leak case and devised doctrine of absolute liability. The Vellore citizen welfare association vs. union of India saw the emergence of well known polluter pays principle.
Hence SC has acted as the protector of India's international commitments in climate change conferences. It has also directed citizens to take proactive steps to protect natural heritage under A '51A(g).
However, environmentalists like R.C. Guha and madhav gadgil in their book, "The fissured land" argue that the corporate capture of state has failed the judicial precedents by neglecting ecological impact of projects such as that by ANIDCO in Andaman and Nicobar, Lakshadweep transshipment port and Silkyara tunnel in Uttarakhand.
The ignorance towards proper EIA, neglect of public hearings and lack of project assessment reports also shows laxity on the part of bureaucracy.
It may be attributed to judiciary's salutory role in protecting environment which breeds both resistance as well as laxity in the bureaucracy and legislators. The judicial interference in policy making instills contempt in the executive due to interference.
However, proactive role of Indian government towards climate change negotiations is evident on global platform. Push for LiFE in COP26, International solar alliance, Global methane pledge and OSOWOG show complementarity of judiciary's role and legislature action.
Moreover, bureaucracy going beyond the mandate of duty for environmental service has attracted media headlines. IAS Rameshwaran Iyer's efforts to like "Tere Mere Beach Mein" to clean Karnataka beaches, IAS Divy-Dawarajan's efforts to increase green cover in Chhattisgarh with community participation are some prominent examples.
IAS Chhavi Chawla has converted Soda village of Rajasthan into a 100% solar village.
All things considered, judicial pronouncements with respect to environmental legislation may give rise to turf strifes with bureaucracy and corporations. Yet Tata and Infosys collaboration with Greenpeace and Vantara initiative of reliance foundation show increasing corporate ethics and bureaucratic initiative for environment protection.