Topper Copies

"Reservation" as an instrument of dialectically linking social justice and electoral politics.

Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025

Having inherited a nation with shattered economy and fragmented society, the constitution makers directed state to make special provisions for marginalised sections under A.46 and A.39.

Affirmative action policies have come a full circle with special provisions for SC/ST, OBCs, EWS (103rd amendment) and finally women reservation (106th amendment)

However, reservation policies are often strategically placed around election years for political mobilisation. Moreover, state sponsored fragmentation (RC Guha) for votebank politics shows that reservation politics has influenced political dynamics along with providing social justice.

The rise of regional parties based on social identities and demanding quota further shows imminent rol of reservation in politics. Most prominent examples are BSP, DMK and Marathas.

Also, the rising demands of dominant caste reservations eg. Marathas, Jats and Gujjars shows the race to the bottom. It not only undermines meritocracy in the system but also creates a domino effect for quota demands.

Pratap Bhanu Mehta rightly highlights that reservation generates more heat than light.

However, reservation's role in electoral politics is saturating with 49.5% reservation with 10% EWS quota. The shift from caste towards religion was evident in 2024 elections.