Topper Copies

The Basic Structure doctrine is not merely a judicial innovation, but also a political intervention.

Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025

The Basic structure doctrine is an innovation by Indian SC in Keshavanand Bharti case to protect the core principles of constitution from the overreach of Parliament's amending power.

Rise of an active judiciary after 1970's gave rise to pro-active role of judiciary in protecting constitutional morality. The inviolability of basic structure is a testament to this.

While the judiciary has left the doctrine as a voyage of discovery by making it open-ended and non codified, it has listed key philosophical principles like secularism (Bommai case), Rule of law (Indira Gandhi vs Raj narain), Judicial review (IR Coelho case) etc under basic structure.

However, the political spillover of judicial innovation has led to a bidirectional influence of basic structure on politics and political landscape on basic structure.

Efforts in 42nd amendment and 39th amendment to limit SC's powers of judicial review led to Rule of law and offices of President and Vice president become a part of basic structure Similarly communal electoral politics led to Bommai Case (Secularism) and misuse of speaker's power and governor's office which made federal structure as a part of basic structure.

While basic structure is often called judicial overreach, political leaders of the time had their own part to play in its formation.