While Indo-US ties have expanded in breadth, they continue to suffer from a lack of strategic depth. Critically evaluate this statement with reference to recent developments.
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
former US President Obama termed Indo-US relations as the most defining relationships of 21st century. PM Modi termed the coming age of AI — America-India age.
Indo-US ties transformed from estranged democracies in bitter Cold war to engaged democracies in post cold war. Post LPG reforms of Narsimhan govt (India) looked for west for trade, development, energy diversification.
It was Vajpayee ji, who termed US as India's Natural Ally. Then Manmohan govt. broke the ice with 2008 Indo-US Civil Nuclear deal. India became strategic defence partner of US and both elevated 2+2 strategic dialogues, without being a formal ally of US, India enjoyed gains of LEMOA, COMCASA, GEMOA & BECA.
The bilateral trade expanded to $120 bn which India-US aims to elevate to $500 bn by 2030. Also, There is COMPACT deal to boost military partnerships, commerce & tech.
On strategic grounds, China became a catalyst for Indo-US alignments such as QUAD in Indo-Pacific. India, also gained dividends in West Asia by leveraging Abraham Accords for I2U2 and IMEC.
On terrorism, both nations collectively introduced resolutions at UNsc. Recently the US extradition of Tahawur Rana and US recognition of TRF as terrorist organization is big gain for New-Delhi.
Despite wide engagements on defence, trade, technology (NISAR AI) and security, there are limitations in strategic depth.
India's strategic autonomy to engage with Russia & Iran despite western sanctions and its presence in non-western architecture of BRICS, SCO, AIIB has irritated USA. Recent tariff attacks by US President Trump on India (25% hike) further dilutes the trust and bonhomie.
India's vision of multipolar World order doesn't naturally fit India vs hegemonic status quoism.
Further, India fails to become US camp follower as Happyman Jacob terms India as itself as a pole in today's world.
There are transactional relations or defence without coproduction and IPR sharing as blocks in DTTC and iCET.
Nevertheless, there is hope of strategic maturity in Washington as well as New Delhi to respect each other's strategic interests and depens their relationships. Only then Indo-US can be the most defining partnership of 21st century.