Topper Copies

Analyze how the formation of coalition governments has deviated from the traditional centralising tendencies associated with Indian Federalism.

Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024

Indian political system is framed by the top-down federal model, electoral means and social cleavages operating in vicinity with time.

Traditionally, after-independence India saw reign of the Congress-dominant system (Rajni Kothari) due to it being the single largest national party (offspring of national movement) in India.

The centralisation was reflected in its operation of the political structure by dismissing governments (Article 365, state-emergency), imposition of Emergency and 42nd constitutional amendment which put Parliament above Judiciary.

Yet, growing discontent, regionalisation of politics, decentralisation of government, all deepened democracy (Yogendra Yadav) and led to dismantling of government into: coalition government.

Coalition governments strengthen the federalism (MP Singh) as these are more diverse & representative democracy. It gives more space to state's demands and policies etc.

Likewise, these are more democratic as Council of ministers and cabinets are representative of whole of India and different regional parties.

This also create a balance between centralising and federalising tendencies of democracy (Christopher Jeffrelot). Thus, these put an end to single party's dominance.

Also better policy making and addressing development-deficit to ensure regional-development paradox are made sure. Vulnerability of coalition depends on managing these challenges.

However, there are problems associated with coalition-governments. [?] uncertainty & Winning the Mandate points that post-poll alliances is a cheating on democracy as they are driven by purely power-view of politics rather than ideological-leaning.

Secondly, policy-paralysis is inherent feature of it as reflected in Indo-US 123 Agreement (Nuclear deal) which took 3 years between 2006-08 to finalize during UPA-I.

Thirdly, coalitions are very less stable as seen in India between (1989-99).

India's growth story requires solid decision making and strong Executive is need of hour.