Topper Copies

Examine the financial difficulties faced by the Panchayati Raj Institutions. (15 marks)

Vikas, AIR 27, 2025

Based on Gandhi's vision of "Gram Raj" for Ram Raj, PRI's have an intrinsic redistributive and instrumental value [Amartya Sen] for good, sustainable and inclusive governance [?],

Established by 73rd Amendment, PRI's face tremendous financial difficulties. Financial powers to PRI's has been delegated to state government which are themselves called as "Closely municipalities" due to lack of sufficient funds. State governments are reluctant to give substantial financial powers to the PRI's.

Government funds and aid under the recommendation of State Finance Commissions under Article 243 I constitute major portion of their finance. Self generation of funds is minimal in PRI's.

Vijay Kelkar held that "Introduction of GST has further constrained the funds to PRI's". World Bank held India as a worst performer in financial decentralisation.

limited funds of PRI's are siphoned by Sarpanch-Bureaucracy-local politicians nexus as held by Manishankar Aiyer Committee.

Expenditure by the Government is at less than 2% of GDP which is less than 14% of GDP by China on its local bodies.

State Governments also donot let PRI's to raise funds from the debt market. "Muni's" or Municipal bonds introduced in 2023 budget caters to only ULB's and not PRI's.

Economic Structure is the basic structure held by Marx. ARC II and NCRWC opined to focus on self generation of funds by PRI's and sufficient devolution of taxation powers to PRI's. Vijay Kelkar held that a part of GST revenue shall be shared with PRI's. Kerala's Big Bang Model of decentralisation focused on adequate funds to PRI's and Andhra Pradesh's village secretariat scheme can be emulated at national levels. To achieve vision of "village Republic" of Gandhi, sufficient funds shall be given to PRI's to build a VIKSIT BHARAT by 2047.