Do you think Indian Parliament has yet to live up to the hopes and aspirations of its founding fathers? (15 marks)
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Indian Parliament is hailed as the "most-dynamic" institution of our democratic republic by Vinod Rai.
Established under Article 79 and modelled on British lines of an upper and lower house, parliament has come under criticism in recent times.
PRS's Legislative Research highlighted that parliamentary sittings have come down to just 55 days in an year in 17th Lok Sabha downgrading deliberative democracy in India.
Use of money bill route, ordinance route and the politicisation of the post of speaker has lowered the credibility of the Parliament.
P.B. Mehta called Parliament as "Notice Board" due to lack of informed debates and deliberations. Its role has been confined to voting lobe in case of farm bills and Agneepath scheme.
Hamid Ansari called Parliament as "federation of Anarchy" due to opposition and ruling parties acting as "warring groups". P.B. Mehta called Parliament as a "self serving institution", due to the "communalisation of politics" for e.g. in 18th lok sabha, 46% of MP's have criminal background, anti defection law has increased hold of political parties over MPs resulting in less dissent.
Issue of whip and lack of use of Parliamentary committees with only 16% of bills referred to them under 17th Lok Sabha has led to crisis of confidence in Parliament.
Parliament in order to address the dreams of founding father has to be reformed and restructured. Venkaiah Naidu gave a 10 point charter for parliamentary reforms. ARC II called for a code of conduct and code of ethics for legislatures, legislative impact Assessment and US Model of strong Parliamentary committees needs to be emulated. A new parliamentary building substantiated by new Parliamentary processes rules is needed to achieve the vision of "VIKASIT BHARAT" by 2047.