"Secularism is one of the most central ideological contestations in Indian politics since Independence" Bring out different perspectives on the nature of Indian Secularism. (20 marks)
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
"Render unto Caesar what is Caesar's and unto Church what is Church's" is the core ideology behind Secularism.
However, western concept of Secularism based on "laicite model" of France based on "thick wall of separation" is a matter of immense debate in Indian polities since Independence.
In constituent assembly, K. M. Munshi pushed for a "characteristically Indian Secularism" as religion is a part of life in India. western model was held as inept because there was no historical conflict in India between the religion and state.
Following this, a positive model of Secularism based on "principled distance" model was adopted as held by Rajiv Bhargava. It was adopted on context of partition & sense of insecurity among the minorities. It was based on Tagorean and Neovedantic vision of "unity in diversity".
After congress system phase [1951-67], words like 'secularism' was explicitly added in Preamble by 42nd Amendment to make the nature of India being a "secular State" explicit.
Indian model of secularism was criticized by scholars like Pratap Bhanu as "extremely weak Model" due to inability to protect tolerance and conflict in society. In 1980's Shah Bano controversy and Mandal politics phase gave a crucial challenge to Indian model of secularism. Scholars like Arun Shourie called it "pseudo secularism"
Scholars like P.B. Mehta held it to be an "asymmetrical model" and it has led to the legitimisation of "vote bank politics" of different political parties. Rajiv Bhargava too called it as "party political secularism"
Supreme court too did not give any specific interpretation of Indian secularism. It dealt with the "contextual Model" with doctrines like Essential practices, constitutional morality from time to time.
Indian Model is highlighted as crucial for the fact that civil society is not present in India & State held to be at the forefront of social reforms considering conservative nature of society.
Debate around Indian secularism has been revived again in context of Triple Talaq and UCC issue in recent times. Supreme court held UCC as a "secular imperative" in Shah Bano case but held the process to UCC shall be gradual in Pannalal case.
UCC controversy is often called as forced secularisation & adoption of "western model" which is not fit to Indian society, held by Charles Taylor.
Law commission's recommendations to introduce UCC in long run by developing "overlapping consensus" in alignment with Indian secularism is the way forward.