Topper Copies

It is often argued that despite intense conflicts, nuclear parity has prevented full-scale war between India and Pakistan. Critically assess this claim.

Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025

The year 1998 saw Pokhran-II, India testing nuclear weapons. In less than three months, Islamabad too tested its own weapons, thereby establishing nuclear parity.

The recent Operation Sindoor, post the April 22 Pahalgam attack, shows that India has changed its paradigm of defence against Pakistan by establishing below-threshold, non-nuclear, conventional attacks that are precise, accurate and non-escalatory.

Despite all the cries of nuclear war and nuclear brinkmanship, both have been averted - active use of nuclear weapons. India's NFU, i.e. No First Use doctrine, has been a deterrent, with its focus on credible minimum deterrence and extraordinary response, keeping Islamabad's fingers away from the trigger.

This, however, has led to new-age warfare of hybrid warfare, asymmetric, with use of drones and non-state actors, creating proxy warfare at the LoC. This is popularly known as the Zia doctrine, bleeding India through a thousand cuts.

While nuclear war has been deterred, it has irked New Delhi with constant smaller-scale, non-escalatory damage, e.g. Balakot, Pulwama, Baramulla, etc.

India's response in Op. Sindoor and the new normal post Sindoor:

1. Will not budge to nuclear blackmail. 2. Deterrence by denial to deterrence by punishment. 3. Terror and talks cannot flow together. 4. No discrimination between non-state actors or state-led terrorism.

This new normal, thus, is the way forward to address small to large conflict.