How have feminist scholars critiqued traditional security paradigms in International Relations and what alternative perspectives on security have they proposed?
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
The realist thinker Morgenthau provided the theory of international politics in his book Politics Among Nations. He takes the viewpoint of man who, according to him, is "animus dominandi".
The feminist scholars of IR like Ann J. Tickner and Cynthia Enloe say the IR theories are masculine in nature and do not feature care, as women face the largest and disproportionate brunt of wars, terrorism, etc.
They call for "care to be securitised" and nationalistic interest to be based on the interests of women.
Since security is a speech act (Barry Buzan), feminists want women's security to be securitised.
Similarly, social constructivists like Martha Finnemore and Nina Tannenwald say that anarchy need not necessarily mean war. Peace can be an option, if it is constructed like that.
Nina Tannenwald goes a step further and says that weapons of mass destruction (WMD), like nuclear weapons, must be tabooed, to make a world peaceful, by naming and shaming countries that proliferate.
Feminist foreign policy has been codified, with Nordic states like Norway being the first to produce one such policy.
However, critics point out the dangers of giving up on weapons as deterrents. Henry Kissinger says feminist policy assumes that states will always act rationally.
Thus, feminist foreign policy scholars' perspectives give a new dimension with 3 Cs: care, cooperation and collaboration as the foundation.