The U.S. has maintained its hegemonic role in global politics, as demonstrated by its influence in the Iran-Israel conflict and India-Pakistan tensions. Discuss critically amid the claims of declining U.S. hegemony in the 21st century.
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
The first half of 2025 saw two extraordinary events in international politics.
1. The bombing of Iran's nuclear facilities at Natanz, Isfahan and Fordow by B2 bombers of USA. 2. The Op. Sindoor, post the Pahalgam attack, which sustained for 72 hrs and was finally ended with a ceasefire, allegedly with US intervention.
However, the hegemonic role of USA in global politics has recently seemed to be declining, according to experts. This is analyzed by the recent article by Prof. Michael Jackius, who says traditionally USA was seen either as an isolationist or as a global superpower acting as a hegemon. However, there's a third route coming up with Trump's transactional politics. This route is a "rogue superpower", that discredits its allies and has no respect for international law or conventions.
For instance, USA's withdrawal from the WHO recently [?] Paris deal is seen as abdication of the duties of a superpower or hegemon.
There is a Kindleberger trap that is getting created, where global distribution of public goods is not happening, similar to what happened during the 1929-30s, as highlighted by Henry Kissinger, leading to the collapse of USA's hegemony.
This is further exacerbated by the rise of the Chinese dragon and its ability to fulfil the Kindleberger trap. This has complicated the issue, with calls of a new cold war and what Graham Allison calls the "Thucydides Trap", similar to Kenneth Organski's Power Transition Theory.
This, along with USA's inward-looking strategies of MAGA, [?] abdicating the security alliance, NATO, has reduced the respect among the allies and adversaries alike.
However, it would be too early and naive to claim the end of USA hegemony.
One instance would be the rapid retaliatory role of the dollar across the globe, and with the Trumpian tariffs set, the hegemony could be further enforced.
Also, the soft power of Washington is more popular and attractive than Beijing, to have any mark as a hegemon, writes Kanti Bajpai.
Thus, USA's hegemony is in transition, and it would be too naive and immature to look at it from any other lens. While challenges remain, USA still hangs around as the hegemon.