While realism focuses on the mechanisms of state behaviour, Marxism focuses on the underlying economic and social forces. Evaluate the statement using examples.
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
Realism is the hegemonic approach in studying international politics. Hans Morgenthau is the intellectual founding father of realism. On the other hand, Marxism, as a philosophical approach, too provides a different worldview to politics.
The foundations of realism are based on the anarchical world that exists and how states are bound to act in a specific way. Scholars like Kenneth Waltz and John Mearsheimer look at it as the state-centric analysis, with states as the primary actors.
According to them, since there is no world government, states are bound to fend for themselves, and because states are power-driven, every state will try for power struggle. Self-help is the way out, and power is the means to it.
At this point, the school of thought diverges into two - offensive realism of Mearsheimer and defensive realism of Waltz.
According to Waltz, states are power maximisers for security, while Mearsheimer disagrees. He says states acquire power for hegemony.
- China's rise as a second pole is not just for security, but counter-hegemony to the USA, e.g. ADB, BRI, CPEC.
Marxism, on the other hand, draws inspiration from Karl Marx's ideas and applies these to IR. The dependency school, led by Immanuel Wallerstein, is a dominant school. He gave the world systems theory, that divides the world into:
Core, periphery and semi-periphery, with states in periphery acting as instruments of states in core, leading to neo-imperialism (Kwame Nkrumah).
Similarly, A.G. Frank and Samir Amin have given the implications of such a system, leading to development of under-development, with imperial rent extraction.
However, the two schools coincide on the aspect of ideology. For Marxism, ideologies are false consciousness, whereas for realists, ideologies are "masks to hide real intentions".
Thus, both provide different insights to international politics. However, realism remains the dominant one, and it is said other approaches remain a footnote to it.