Topper Copies

Analyse the historical approach to studying comparative politics.

Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025

Apter defines comparative politics as the science of finding patterns in different political systems.

Historical approach, along with legal-constitutional, has been the dominant approach to comparative politics in the pre-World War era.

The approach draws from comparing the history of countries' constitutions, legal systems, rules and values.

This helped in creating the first model framework for comparative politics. However, this approach is not without faults.

Roy Macridis calls it narrow, prejudiced, non-comparative and limited. Because, in effect, it was comparing the histories of western world countries and ended up having same or similar results.

Moreover, it is eurocentric and ethnocentric, so it doesn't apply to third countries where there is a mismatch between text and constitution/context, as highlighted by F.W. Riggs, since they are traditional societies.

Thus, historical approach is insufficient and later approaches like systems, modernization, political sociology approach need to be used in tandem to better appreciate the third world and others in general.