Do you agree that Finance Commission is the balancing wheel of fiscal federalism in India?
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
'Kosh' is one of the seven limbs of State. according to Kautilya's Saptang Theory. Treasury ensure State can carry out its functions and protect its sovereignty.
In this regard, finance Commission under A.280 ensure State's treasury is used in the best interest of State and finances are devolved in accordance with constitutional mandate.
It act as balancing wheel of fiscal federalism by fulfilling its mandate as given in constitution -
1. Determine principles to guide grant in aids from Centre to State. 2. formulate plan to distribute centre's receipts to states, equitably among various states (horizontal & verticle devolution) 3. Measures to augment resources of State finance Commission to supliment grants for local government. 4. Any other duty by President.
15 th finance Commission fulfilled its duty of fiscal federalism by suggesting 41% of tax devolution to states. This ensured state's fiscal health is improved. Additionally, various grants based on different conditions were recommended. It also ensured States get due weightage in categories of population, forest cover etc.
But at the same time, it's effectiveness is limited due to its recommendatory nature. States alleges that they are discriminated. eg- Southern States against devolution based on population. States also want share in cess & surcharges of Centre, in which finance Commission can't interfere.
overall, finance Commission has upholded its envisaged role by acting with integrity and wisdom to ensure fiscal federalism.