Critically examine the relevance of Marxist perspective on national movement.
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
Indian National movement has been analysed by different scholars and activities between 1857-1947 is seen by some as nationalist while others criticise it.
Marxist analyse national movement on the framework of class and class hierarchy. MN Roy provides Criticism of Indian National Congress calling it a party of Bourgeois class.
He, in his book 'India in Transition' called INM as Bourgeois conspiracy and Gandhi as Bourgeois leader.
Similar views are expressed by other scholars like R.P. Dutt.
Relevance of this approach lies in providing a indepth analysis of class character of INC which can't be ignored.
Analyzing INM from perspective of weaker class and sub-altern gives more holistic understanding of these activities.
Neo-marxist like Bipin Chandra compare Gandhian style with Gramsci' idea of movement of manoeuvre → position and ideological hegemony.
At the same time, they are biased in their approach as said by Sumit Sarkar. INC was indeed a national party and multi-class movement was launched against british.