Topper Copies

Discuss whether an active non-alignment provides a viable foreign policy option for middle powers amid great power rivalries.

Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025

The legacy of non-alignment dates back to cold war rivalry b/w US & USSR where Afro-Asian powers stood for one world.

In post-Cold war era, there is rising great power rivalry promoting authoritarianism and populism. As the Western powers are pursuing protectionism (e.g. Anti-immigration stance of Trump).

The rising rivalry between US, China and Russia are giving the indications of Cold War 2.0 or Bipolar world order. In such a faulted world order, middle power suffers from constrained choices; less of soft-balancing for better trade deals and technological share.

In this scenario, active non-alignment becomes a viable option. As T.V. Paul argued it promotes normative a voice of Global South for issues such as Climate injustice, IPR bottlenecks on life saving diseases and adequate capital & tech-sharing.

Further, it prevents the scope of satellites as bandwagoners with limited economic sovereignty amongst the great powers.

However, as EAM Jaishankar argued contemporary world order is not of non-alignment but of multi-alignment. Middle Powers like BRICS are navigating better through hedging => maximum engagement without antagonising any power.

This is the policy of multi-vector diplomacy (C. Rajamohan) of India to integrate diverse landscapes such as BRICS, SCO, QUAD, FIPIC, I2U2, G20 for issue-based minilateralism.

Harsh V. Pant also argued that non-alignment today is a luxury which can't be afforded Global South in the world of convergences.

Nevertheless, Suhasini Haidar underscores the need of reinventing NAM for normative justice through institutionalisation of Charter on global norms based on equity & justice.