7.b) Culture is unique to human beings. Do you agree? Present arguments in favour and against the statement. (15 marks)
Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024
Culture is man-made part of environment (Herskovitz).
Within the framework of this definition, culture would not be unique to humans because primates can also create, yet culture may be considered unique because: 1. Ideational: only humans conceptualise & ideate 2. Transmitted: not instinctual like primates/animals 3. Symbolic: symbolic expression is exclusive to human beings 4. Integrated: patterned into a mosaic that can only be identified by other humans 5. Needs external impetus for propagation: culture does not automatically flow
Causes for culture being exclusive 1. Brain capacity in qualitative aspects, not quantitative 2. Ability to transmit & communicate symbolically: creation of syntax & vocabulary 3. Thumb opposition: uniquely placed to hold objects, dexterity 4. Social institutions created
Culture therefore is super organic (Kroeber, based on Spencer) and is exclusive to human beings.
Arguments against
1. Language learnt by Chimpanzee in captivity in USA (symbolic communication isn't exclusive) 2. Even gorillas have society & stratification in society: silverback gorilla, mother gorilla 3. Tool use found by orangutans as well, honey stick dipping 4. Feeling of community, well entrenched
As the apex species, humans uniquely have culture, as Jane Goodall puts it: "Man's first tryst with culture was the discovery of a broken/healed femur, because it implied that he was taken care of."