6.c) Consumption is always social even when it addresses physical needs. Elaborate (15 marks)
Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024
The concept of Boas refers to conspicuous consumption by them during Potlach as a means of demonstrating power, superiority, and self-esteem.
Hence consumption can be social even when it addresses physical needs, because redistribution may be deemed to be a "necessity", but the aspect of social glorification cannot be wished away.
Where Consumption is social & physical 1. Conspicuous consumption: greater showcase of power through ostentatiousness & donning exclusive finery (eg: large "Big Fat Indian" wedding in South India, even at cost of significant credit disability, showmanship) 2. Non-productive destruction of wealth: Potlatch. Competitive potlatch involves outdoing each other during the process of material destruction 3. Large scale bets placed on Sambugan; Clifford Geertz's symbolism in Java: bets placed higher when people of similarly situated social positions are vying against each other 4. African tribe: a man's wealth is gauged by the girth of his belly, indicative of prosperity
However, not all consumption has social connotations
1. Tribal subsistence living: the Korwa tribe does not have social implications to feasting 2. Consumption by "bands", eg Eskimos, do not concern social bonds. In winter, less resource [?]; in summer, greater resource, wastage of food. Here food is treated only as a physical entity to satisfy needs
In Malinowski's Theory of Needs, he refers to hunger as a secondary need that needs satiation, while there exists some punishment (eg: [?], where social control also dictates mourning feast to mend ties), largely. The tribal situation, since it is tied to social context, generally has consumption extending beyond just physical satisfaction.