Topper Copies

6.b) To what extent has anthropology's colonial legacy shaped the formation and evolution of its conceptual frameworks, theoretical constructs, and epistemological paradigms? (15 marks)

Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024

Anthropology is perhaps a colonial handmaiden, with Anthropological beginning in India traced to the Asiatic Society of Bengal (1784).

Anthropology, as per Vidyarthi's four-fold classification, in its formulation stage in India is owed to colonialist ethnography, eg Shakespeare's work in Cooch Behar.

Besides, the very need for administering India better led to colonial ethnography and survey needs.

Colonial legacy on Conceptual framework

1. Ideas of evolutionism

data aggregated from researchers. It led to an evolutionary schema: Savagery - Barbarism - Civilisation (LH Morgan)

- Concept of "white man's burden": maintain supremacy, early colonisers wanted to civilize the modern world - Archaeological Survey of India under aegis of R.E.M Wheeler contributed to Indus Valley Civilization excavation as well as commissioning monument conservation (eg: Hampi, Vijaynagara) - Survey (Census survey and Caste enumeration) as a concept to administer masses - Wholly Excluded Area (Partially Excluded Area) as precursor for Scheduled Area for tribal conservation

Theorized constructs of Anthro

- Cultural relativism: bulldozed by exposure to diverse Indian belief (eg: Marvin Harris, citi cow in India for cultural materialism) - Diffusionism: using the civilisational approach of Redfield etc. to formulate the Rural-Urban continuum, present in studies in India

Functionalist paradigms

Anthros, primarily aided by colonialists, attempt to discover what drives India's mentality.

In order to govern, they commissioned a Dept of Anthropology (Bombay) in 1920, while also conferring S C Roy & L. Ananthakrishnan significant academic positions to consult on tribal issues.