Topper Copies

Q.5) Answer the following in about 150 words each: 10x5=50 5.a) Psychology and Anthropology 5.b) Anthropological interpretations of Power 5.c) Subculture and Contraculture 5.d) Customary laws as a tool for environmental conservation 5.e) Idea Culture Configuration by Kroeber

Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024

(a) Psychology and Anthropology

Anthropology as a social science borrows from and deeply impacts Psychology.

Anthropology influencing Psychology 1. Psychic Unity of Mankind Theory (Bachofen, L H Morgan): to imply human thought process everywhere is the same 2. Culture Personality school - R Benedict's Culture Personality theory and patternation [?] of culture - Modal Personality (Cora du Bois) - National Character Studies (Benedict, R Gorer) 3. Symbolic Anthropology & Cognitive Anthropology: structure of mind & thought process

Psychology influencing Anthropology 1. Sigmund Freud's Psychodynamic Theory of Incest Taboo 2. Freud's impact on Malinowski's work and [?] Strauss' interpretation of totemism (binary opposition) 3. Theory of Oedipus Complex and family disintegration 4. Tools used by Cora du Bois, mind maps etc. to arrive at Modal personality 5. Imprint on Linguistic Anthropology by German Psychologists

Yet Anthropology as a holistic science differs from Psychology because of area of concern (society vs individual), methods (cross-cultural study vs individual examination), theorizing (universal laws formulation) using principles such as emic and etic, and holism in approach.

(b) Anthropological interpretations of Power

Weber's description of Power entails an ability of an individual to attain his goal despite resistance.

Lindberg's classification

John Rathe (1945) says power must be classified based on whether:

While institutionalised power is authority (Ronald Dahl, Structure of Power), legitimacy is the key principle determining acceptance.

Features of power 1. Not institutionalised by nature 2. Amorphous, not as easily identified as authority 3. Present in both Democracy & Autocracy 4. Segmentary: distributed 5. Higher power: greater difficulty in removing said power

Case study: In Potlatch, power is described by amount of wealth destroyed, or gifts given, as against the traditional understanding of power where an element of coercion is present.

Weber further exemplifies how the concept of power is amorphous in anthropological context.

(c) Subculture and Contraculture

While the individual unit making up culture (eg: Indian spiritualism made of the subculture of Yoga) is subculture, contraculture are elements that don't integrate well into the entire cultural complex.

Using R. Benedict's patternism of culture, breaking down culture into subunits allows us to determine whether each unit is harmonic or dysharmonic.

E. Leach in Pulaya: A Village in Ceylon sees how many sub-units of culture fuse to make the larger culture complex.

Components of subculture 1. Must have independent existence (eg: veganism as a cultural tradition within a naturalist eating pattern) 2. Must be diffusible, borrow & adopt to other parts of culture

Contraculture refers to elements that may seem to be a disharmony.

Ex. An institution of marriage, culture of open marriage i.e. open sexual activity not restricted to a marital partner, will strain the institution of marriage, because G.P. Murdock (Social Structure, '49) believes sexual monopoly is a prerogative of marriage.

Hence, culture & contraculture evolve hand in hand within the larger processes of diffusion, leading to dynamic change to cultural institutions.

(d) Customary laws as a tool for environmental conservation

Nature-Man-Spirit Complex

L.P Vidyarthi, in Maler, specs of coherent tribal attributes of protectionism towards environment because it is integrated in their living cycle.

Customary laws as tool

Case Study: the Hornbill conservation in Nagaland through enlisting local population led to increased numbers through JFM, reminding the tribe of their ritualistic duties.

The Maldhari Community & Gir forest conservation -> lion population coexistence.

Environmental Conservation proceeds through: - "Sacred groves": animism, principle belief in a living soul inside plants, eg Santhals - "Natureism": Bondas, worshipping of natural phenomenon itself - Sarna tradition of tribals: towards plantation

Within the context of increasing environmental conservation (India net-zero by 2030) through movements such as deep ecology, wherein ecology is praised as an end in itself, the example of Salumarada Thimakka (Soliga tribal woman), recipient of Padma Sri, is needed for environmental conservation.