3.c) How does Polanyi's understanding of the social embeddedness of economic activity challenge traditional conceptions of the economy as a separate sphere of life? (15 marks)
Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024
Karl Polanyi, a substantivist, understands the world through the social context of embeddedness, as mentioned in his Economy as an instituted process.
Cook refers to the Substantivist versus Formalist debate as reinvigorating the economic anthropology discipline, wherein traditional (Formalism) is challenged.
Formalists (Herskovitz, Schneider & Sahlins) argue: 1. Rationality principle: why they produce optimally 2. Maximisation principle: best use of resources 3. Market principles: profit & loss 4. Scarcity assumption, argued that universal principles apply to tribals as well
Karl Polanyi and colleagues (Dalton, Bohanan, Sahlins) argue the economic sphere of tribals is distinct, must be understood in its own context only. They defy: 1. Rationality principle (eg: Kwakiutl feast (Boas), destruction of wealth in Potlach) 2. Maximisation principle (eg: Kerkure tribe (Carneiro), work only 3½ hours a day) 3. Market principles -> Reciprocity, Redistribution, Domestic transaction; do not preference profit (eg: Silent Barter -> price-formation (Polanyi), value of goods transferred not equal) (eg: Meithen highlanders trade with Athabascan)
Hence: 1. The economy does not have an independent existence (eg: Market of Tiv of Nigeria used for special announcements) 2. Every economic action does not necessarily mean economic intent (eg: Trobrianders Kula ring (Gimwali) (utilitarian) vs Maori (non-utilitarian)) 3. Coexists with other institutions (eg: Religion, Kula for better catch of fish) (eg: Social cohesion, Ibo market ring) 4. Solidarity and kinship is at heart of tribal economy
With changing times, mode of exchange (currency) permeating tribal culture, it is more pertinent to study longitudinal changes due to market forces while recognising tribals as optimisers, not vagabonds (Sahlins).