Q.1) Write notes on the following in 150 words 10*5=50 1.a) Cultural shock and reverse culture shock 1.b) Janet Carsten's concept of relatedness in Kinship studies 1.c) Division of Labour 1.d) Problems of Pastoralists in India 1.e) Is Joint Family dying in India
Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024
(a) Cultural shock and reverse culture shock
Culture as defined by EB Tylor in Primitive Society (1871) is the complex of whole knowledge, belief, law, art, morals etc. learnt by man as a member of society.
Cultural shock pertains to the phenomenon of recognition of differences between one's own culture and the culture encountered (eg: Cannibalism among Angami Nagas as a shock to colonial ethnographers).
Contemporary relevance 1. Due to globalization, culture shocks occur owing to frequent movement of people & ideas (eg: Chinese practise of dog eating as a shock)
Closely related to ideas of diffusion and acculturation, culture shock may lead to: (a) Integration (adaptation of practises) (b) Rejection (continuation of earlier practises)
Counter culture shock is the recognition of changes occuring in native land by foreign individuals, eg Traditional families' disbelief at LGBTQ movement in India.
Contemporary relevance: 1. Increasing Xenophobia (migrant attacks), need for tolerant attitude towards diverse culture (cultural relativism of F Boas) 2. 'Emic' understanding may increase harmony in society
(b) Janet Carsten's concept of relatedness in Kinship studies
Kinship is the web of social relations by which an individual is related to others by birth/blood/marriage.
Kinship studies tend to understand the idea of society through functional/structural approaches, because it's the very idea of existence (Leach).
Concept of relatedness 1. Degree to which the individual is related to the others 2. Kindred: diverse set of relations, far related, hence not a reliable social security in times of need
But Filiation (parent, child, son) is a closer association leading to greater security (eg: Filiocentrism in family focused on child)
In lineage systems, eg Tsembaga (rather lineal, exogamous units) studied by Roy A. Rappaport, the clan relies on its extended family of Maring speakers on Papua New Guinea.
Here, Kaiko (pig feast) is performed following planting yams into the ground; they integrate into new clans.
Relatedness also speaks of the ability of non-lineage kin who can perform functions such as: 1. Rites de passage (eg: women go up to father's house for pregnancy) 2. Breaking blood feuds (dispute solving) 3. No conflict with ego, hence ego-protective functions
Relatedness helps understand kinship as an order of existence.
(c) Division of Labour
Division of labour can be traced to pre-hominin species such as Neanderthals and primate species (Gorilla) studied by Fossey, making this cultural tool an evolutionary landmark for progress.
Division of labour parameters 1. Nature (Prestige of Job) 2. Hunting-Gathering (Jaraway of Andaman): male-hunters, female-gatherers, due to prestige and risk associated 3. Within society: specialisation (woodwork, blacksmith etc.) leading to civilisational development (formation of state) 4. Based on environmental conditions: Eskimos do not distinguish between men and women during scarce months
Functions of DoL / origin of DoL 1. Bio-cultural evolution: women's pelvis small -> small brain skull of child; men hunt, women do childcare -> man-woman pair, greater dependence period 2. Structural perspective (R.G Brown on Andamanese): Division of labour leads to structural continuity and cohesion by creating a patriarchal/patrilineal system
Contemporary relevance 1. Industrialisation/modernisation: newer institutions (child care centres) lead to redundancy of dependence, marriage breakdown (Chicago school Social Breakdown theory) 2. Claudia Goldin (U-shaped hypothesis): women equally earning as men, hence no strict division of labour exists on sexual differences, only on meritorious considerations (eg: Sunita Williams, astronaut in space)
(d) Problems of Pastoralists in India
Pastoralism is a means of subsistence living wherein the primary mode of production is cattle/milch, distribution (exchange), and consumption is primarily dairy products.
Features 1. Primarily tribal, but also includes OBC's (Kamma Reddys in Andhra, Kurubas in Karnataka)
[a hand-drawn outline map of India labelled "fig 1: Distribution", marking Maldharis near Gujarat and Rajasthan, transhumance by Bhotiyas and Gaddis in the north, and Todas in the Nilgiris in the south]
2. Religious inclination: spirit (ancestor worship) 3. Kinship ties: strong 4. Politically weak, because no permanent habitation
Problems 1. Government Apathy: colonially some considered criminals (habitual offenders) for breaking forest laws 2. Lack of pastoral grounds (eg: Gaddis, transhumance grounds badly lost) (eg: Ladakh, Chinese intrusion into Pashmina rearing region) 3. Recognition of rights under FRA lacking, cannot infringe on protected area 4. Socio-cultural backwardness: Xaxa Committee says poverty has increased over 50 years 5. Political capital lacking: voting rights are not granted due to frequent migration
Recommendations 1. Comprehensive survey to identify issues 2. A separate commission to deal with them (Renke committee recd.)
Within the ambit of nature-man-spirit complex, sustainable pastoralists must be given rights under FRA.
(e) Is Joint Family dying in India
Joint Family as defined by Irawati Karve has features of common kitchen, common roof, common prayer hall, and a patriarch to direct usage of common property.
Joint family has undergone modifications in India (Census 2011), but nature depends on specific circumstances.
[a hand-drawn family-tree diagram, "fig 1. Joint family", using triangles and circles to show generations and family members]
Joint family dying 1. Individualisation/Modernisation: money economy, women's education, mobility, collapse of household as a unit 2. Education: better opportunities 3. Individuality reassertion through moving out: neo-locality
Joint family Thriving 1. MS Gore: Agrarian family of Delhi continues to remain intact despite values changing (no longer oldest person driving decision) 2. Milton Singer: advertisement in Chennai continues to exist, prevents wealth being distributed 3. K M Kapadia and I P Desai also show only some families show change
The Census 2011 shows Joint family being important again due to high cost-of-living, socialisation of child (grandparents), social capital.
Contemporary trends: while it has declined in the west, in America, in Europe (Clayworth's null hypothesis) it remains intact, implying India can also resist breakdown despite ill effects of industrialisation.