Topper Copies

Discuss the nature of demands of LGBTQ movements in India.

Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024

LGBTQ+ rights movement in India are the social movements demanding right to sexual orientation under the ambit of right to life under Article 21.

Shashi Tharoor writes that "the demand of LGBTQ groups are demand for basic human rights denied to them due to "retrogressive thought-process of society against heterogeneity"."

Thus, LGBTQ movements demand right to recognition, legalisation of same-sex marriages, right to residence and cultural rights in democratic society.

These demands are inspired by the global LGBTQ movements, gay-pride rallies and independent groups across countries like we are One in USA etc. Thus, these are essentially western in origin.

Secondly, these are rights demand directed against state. Carol Hanisch wrote that; "when she looks at the state, it appears male to her", thus, these movement challenge the state's discrimination of men, women and third sex in granting rights or framing policies.

Thirdly, these movements also align with radical feminist call for challenging patriarchy with which enforces "homogeneity". Ambedkar's writings that by nature, society has never just been heterogenous and same-sex attraction has been the norm.

Fourth, these movements in India are still mostly organized amidst civil society organizations. These are also mostly urban-based educated people movements like pride rally in Delhi, Bhopal etc.

However, Supreme Court in Navtej Singh Johar case has given these movement a "social recognition" by de-criminalizing homosexuality.

Love is independent and thus, LGBTQ association is important factor in extending rights to vulnerable.