Whether judicial activism has undermined or strengthened Parliamentary Democracy in India . Discuss. (15 marks)
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Constitution establishing a democratic system while adopting a Parliamentary system has adopted the doctrines like "separation of powers" with "interlinking and interdependence among three branches based on doctrine of "checks and balances".
Judicial activism has promoted judiciary's proactive role in delivering justice to the people. From 1973 Keshavanand Bharati's case till now, is called as phase of judicial activism.
However, it remains a matter of debate among scholars whether it has strengthened or weakened democracy. Scholars like Upendra Baxi hailed it as charioteer of emergence Indian polities", B.G. Modi held that "judicial activism through basic structure doctrine saved the parliamentary democracy in India from crumbling. It has led to control over "Bonapartist executive", to prevent it from overstepping from its jurisdiction.
Menka Gandhi case of 1978 where supreme court adopted due process of law furthered the cause of delivering substantive justice by allowing parliament to pass laws that are "fair, just and reasonable" based on "principles of natural justice".
However scholars like P.B. Mehta held that "Judiciary in the name of activism has strengthened its role- VIS-A-VIS other two organs, It has assumed powers of constituent Assembly and become a superlegislature violating delicate balance of power under parliamentary democracy.
Collegium system as a result of judicial activism has led to formation of "IMPERIUM IN IMPERIO" [Ambedkar]. Bhikhu Parekh called India a case of "judicial conformism" and P. B. Mehta called judicial activism as a case of "judicial sovereignty".
However, it has to be noticed that activism by judiciary has delivered substantive justice in form of PIL, decriminalisation of sec.377 and enforcement of principle of constitutionalism. It has prevented the "sanctity of constitution", Rule of law, separation of power and doctrine of checks and balances from excessive [?]-headedness especially during emergency, as held by N. A. Palkhivala so judicial activism shall be a "Alarm clock" and not a "time keeper".