While realism focuses on the mechanisms of state behaviour, Marxism focuses on the underlying economic and social forces. Evaluate the statement using examples.
Simrandeep Kaur, AIR 15, 2025
Realism is the hegemonic discourse of IR with its timeless analysis of power-struggle and International Anarchy. Marxism on the other hand is a critical reflection on global Capitalism led exploitations.
Realism, state-centric world view, focuses on the mechanism of state behaviour. Classical realists such as Hans Morgenthau (Politics among States) held that pessimistic human nature causes foreign policy of state based on power-struggle.
for instance, Iran's foreign policy towards Israel focuses on considering realpolitik balance for Israel as persistent threat for Islam. This demonstrates lack of trust and Prisoner's dilemma as described by Thomas Schelling.
Structural realist such as Kenneth Waltz (The theory of International Relations) observed the anarchical structure as the real scientific cause behind state's constrained choices and security maximization. For example, in Operation Sindoor, the anarchical terrorism required strategic retaliation from India towards Pakistan.
Further, neo-realist J. Mearsheimer advocate for power-maximization as there is less possibility of resolving security dilemma. This explains the Aggressions of Russia on Ukraine to retaliate with offensive security against NATO.
Marxism, on Contrary, is a analytical and prescriptive approach to IR. Karl Marx held that the profit maximization will force Bourgeoisie to settle & nestle everywhere.
Marxism focuses on the underlying social and economic forces. As Dependency scholars (AG. Frank and Samir Amin) highlighted the unequal exchange between Global North and Global South. The advanced Industrialization of west (AI, IPR, IoT, Defence tech) is advanced through the exploitation of global south (African scramble 2.0)
Immanual Wallerstein in world system theory further highlighted role of Semiperipheries in sustaining the exploitation
Also, the Gramscian scholar Robert Cox analyzed the hidden capitalist motive behind USAID, BRI. Andrew Linklater (critical school) prescribed for dilution of boundaries on immigration debates.
Thus, Realism and Marxism describes the power-struggle and underlying structures in the IR.