Topper Copies

क्या आप सहमत हैं कि क्रियात्मकता (Functionalism) का सिद्धांत विरोधाभासी एवं अस्पष्ट है? Do you agree that the theory of functionalism is contradictory and vague?

Apurva Verma, AIR 42, 2025

The theory of functionalism is based on principles of liberalism. It is an institution based and society focused theory which believes in learning through cooperation model.

The theory of functionalism is based on ideas of scholars like Karl Deutsch, David Mitrany. They believe that states are rational actor. They will cooperate for the purpose of peace and stability. The issues to be tackled are bundled and focus is on learning to harvest low-hanging fruit. This compartmentalisation of issues is unique.

Further, functionalists believe that politicians need to be kept out of the process. Chance has to be given to civil societies and focus on track-II diplomacy. Once it is successful, state will themselves realise that there is no use of war, instead they should focus on becoming security community.

However, contradiction emerges when scholars assume that states will be rational and not give primacy to their national interest. International politics has been compared to an anarchical society by Hedley Bull, and states only appear to be responsible rather than being actually responsible.

Also, the assertion to keep politicians out is vague, because political will is the basic ingredient for the success of becoming a security community. The example of EU, which is the foundation for functionalist model even is based on political will and national interest. The exit of Britain from EU highlights this.

Theory of functionalism is based on normative ideas but for it to be successful, it need to incorporate the realist perspective also leading to a final synthesis.