Topper Copies

Discuss the role of Supreme Court as the final interpreter of the Indian Constitution.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

"The best test of excellence of any government is the functioning of its judiciary" - Lord Bryce.

In India,this quote is realised by Supreme Court who act as, final interpreter of constitution, supreme authority in federal disputes, guardian of rights of Individuals etc.

Supreme Court is envisaged to act as guardian of constitution, so it has power to interpret constitution by removing ambiguities. In this role, Fundamental Rights, DPSP act as key to mind of constitution makers for SC.

This power is realised through judicial review and advisory jurisdiction of SC. In Shankari Prasad Case, SC interpreted amending power and position of Fundamental rights in constitution (A-13).

Similarly in Golaknath case, it reversed its earlier interpretation (FR can be amended) by saying FR as immutable and inviolatable.

Kesivanand Bharati Case was epitome of Judicial creativity in interpreting ideals of constitution, giving true doctrine of Basic Structure. This doctrine helped in saving the soul of constitution, protecting fundamental ideals.

Its power is criticised by Pratap bhanu mehta saying SC is a self-perpetuating institution. Judges act on individual parameters, no overarching principles. It's paradoxical and go for image building. Judiciary interpret according to its whims & fancies.

But SC has safeguarded the social contract built by founding fathers reflecting general will. It requires creativity and courage to interpret in good manner.