Topper Copies

In India, though political decentralisation has been successfully achieved through the establishment of local government bodies, the actual transfer of functions, finances, and functionaries to these institutions remains incomplete. Critically analyse.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

Political decentralisation is based on Gandhi's idea of village republics ensuring Sarvodaya and antodya by giving power to lower levels of governance. This is a bottom up approach against traditional top down approach.

The journey started in India with DPSP Article 42 aiming for village panchayats. In the beginning, Panchayat Raj system was voluntary leading to state wise variations.

Various Committees (Balwant Rai Mehta and Ashok Mehta) suggested to constitutionalise panchayat system in order to strengthen it and bring uniformity across nation.

73rd and 74th amendment Act constitutionalised village panchayati raj and urban local governance in the Country.

It provided for 3-tier structure - Village → Block → District level - completing decentralisation of political power.

But voluntary provisions in the act provide state's autonomy in transferring 3Fs - funds, functions & functionaries.

local governments continue to face financial difficulties as state's devolution is meagre and in the form of tied- expenditure on government schemes.

11th and 12th schedule aimed to devolve functions of local governance like maintaining ponds, cattle, parks etc but actual situation is worse.

They don't perform these functions effectively as they lack capacity and training.

functionaries also didn't perform as envisaged. local government don't have their own cadre of officers and bureaucrats attitude is against these elected members.

These issues are due to lack of political will at state level.

As Ashok Mehta committee said, the local government system was made to fail due to conspiracy of Centre, State and bureaucracy.

State didn't devolve 3Fs as they themselves are "Glorified Municipalities" means they don't have enough resources themselves. State finance Commission is also not effective due to State's apathy.

After 32 years of constitutionalisation, PRI's has achieved a lot in terms of democracy at grassroot level but there is a long road to go. As Manishanker Committee said, 'Bad PRI is worse than no PRI'.