India's nuclear doctrine is more about political signalling than operational planning. Critically examine this assertion.
Rakhi, AIR 65, 2025
India became a nuclear weapon state, when it underwent the Pokhran Tests, with official statement after operation Smiling Buddha (1998), under Vajpayee government.
India's nuclear doctrine is based on 'No first use policy', where nuclear bombs would be used only in the second instance as a reaction to nuclear attacks by other nation.
Moreover, it refrains from using it against civilians and innocents. Yet, it can be used in first instance in response to a large scale destruction due to chemical and biological weapons.
This policy and doctrine reveals India's priority for peace and humanity, and development of nuclear power only as a deterrent, which according to Kenneth Waltz, is the new weapon of peace.
This reflects only a political signalling, rather than operational planning reflecting 'deterrence by denial' and not 'deterrence by punishment'.
This strategy has failed to deter Pakistan in form of non-state and terrorist actors such as seen during Pathankot attack.
However, it is found useful, as despite small skirmishes, there has been no full scale war, involving the two ideals.
Moreover, India favours peace and dignity of human life, which can be hampered due to use of nuclear weapons, as operational planning.
India is in side of peace and as per S. Jaishankar, this is not an era of war. India prioritises its national interest and strategic autonomy which can only be achieved by focusing on its economic growth.
Thus, the civilisational India favours soft power, over hard power, and its people promotes peace and co-operation throughout the world, with the values of one earth, one family.