Topper Copies

Discuss boundary disputes between different states. Explain what are different methods available to resolve inter-state disputes. (20 Marks)

Vikas, AIR 27, 2025

Indian federation of 28 states and 8 UT's is often called as holding together federalism and not coming together federalism like the federation of Canada.

Louis Tillin in her book 'Remapping India' held that "political map of India is yet not settled". It is clearly evident from the boundary disputes between the states right from independence.

Just after independence, State reorganisation based on linguistic recommendations of Dhar commission in 1953, led to a debate on the border disputes among states.

In 1967-89 era, and in era of coalition politics in 1989-2014 with the rise of regional parties, boundary disputes became common due to the mobilisation of people by regional parties. At present the disputes over Belgaum between Maharashtra and Karnataka, over chandigarh between Haryana and Punjab, over Kotia between Andhra Pradesh and Odisha, over tribal regions between Assam and Manipur can be seen across the country.

Belgaum dispute is due to language which led to Mahajan Commission formation. Chandigarh issue is due to economic and administrative reason, But the most common reason behind the boundary disputes is the mobilisation by political parties in those state.

In his book, "Inter State Border disputes", Ashok Swain held that lack of political will, politics of opposition parties, colonial history and struggle over resources like water and minerals are the major reason behind the border disputes among states.

To resolve these disputes, Ashok Swain suggested the use of cooperative mechanisms like Inter State councils and zonal councils to solve them in a very amicable manner. The role of regional parties and leaders is to give primacy to the interests of the people leaving aside the political interests.

Various organs hold that centre shall act as a facilitator to resolve the disputes among the states helping them to reach a compromise.

The Sarkaria Commission and Punchhi commission also recommended to use the method of Plebiscite to decide the fate of region with bodies like Inter State Council acting as a unifying mechanism.

But unfortunately, instead of amicable settlements, these disputes have led to litigation under Article 131, original jurisdiction of supreme court leading to delays in resolving these disputes.

India as a "cooperative federalism" [Granville Austin] has to solve these disputes in a very cooperative manner with centre acting as a "guide" to States