Analyse the contrasting philosophies of Mahatma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru which have left an essence in Part IV of our constitution. (10 Marks)
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
There has been an ideological difference in the philosophies of Mahatma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru
Nehru was a modernist and he favoured a progressive Model of socialism based on the success of USSR emphasizing on Planning & Public sector
Gandhi on the other hand, believed in concept of village republics and 'Sarvodaya' through his principles of Bread labour, Swadeshi, Theory of trusteeship, Ahimsa and revival of cottage industries.
Nehru emphasised on modern industrialization to revive India whereas Gandhi criticized modern industrial civilisation in his article Hindutva-Ideas and [?].
Gandhian idea of local government found place in Article 40 and cottage industries in Article 43 of DPSP's. Nehru, as a Modernist emphasized on modern means for Regeneration of India, keeping the Gandhian ideas in DPSP's which serve as a "Instrument of Instructions" for the formation of public policy and establishment of a welfare State under Article 38.
Ignorance of Gandhian Ideas led to K-shaped Growth and huge inequalities as evident in Oxfam report where 1% hold more than 40% of wealth and also conflict between DPSP's & fundamental rights leading to excessive judiciary tussles and judicial activism in form of Basic Structure doctrine and Constitutional Amendments