Topper Copies

Discuss the reasons for the environmental movement in India.

Abhi Jain, AIR 34, 2024

Environmental movements are reflective of the citizens concern for Mother Nature's protection and preservation.

As Ramchandra Guha in "The Unquiet Woods" writes: "polluted rivers, degraded lands and displaced tribals" are all we have after 70 years of India's Independence..." thus, environmental movement reflect these issues.

Firstly, India's environmental movements in contrast to the west are - movements of 'survival' rather than affluence. For instance, the Vedanta vs. Niyamgiri protest was concerned more about the livelihood & habitat rights of jan-jatis (tribes) in Niyamgiri hills of Odisha than environment per se.

Secondly, these are non-institutional and unorganised. As they arise on need-basis and are sporadic in nature. Like the Aarey forest protest in Mumbai against felling of trees for Metro.

Thirdly, ecofeminists like Vandana Shiva posits these movements are reflection of failure of state's policies. For instance, the soil degradation, water pollution due to chemical fertilisers usage during Green revolution.

Fourth, the urban-educated society's consciousness is reflected as voice for controlling air pollution in Delhi or crusading Gandhians protesting industrialisation along Narmada.

Western environmentalism is winning (influenced UNFCCC) due to more institutional & government recognition. Barry Buzan- B securitised the environmental issues.