What are the controversies associated with the post of Governor? Evaluate the significance of Governor in India's federal setup.
Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025
Governor is the head of the state as parliamentary System require real (CM) and nominal head for functioning.
1. Article 153: states there shall be a governor for each state. Article 154 says governor shall exercise executive power either directly or through subordinates appointed by him.
Office of governor has dual role: head of state and representative of Centre in states. It's an independent office of dignity to ensure state governance is in accordance with constitution.
Controversies
1. Openly criticising government - seen in west bengal and Tamil Nadu. The ideal is to have private conversation about vacancies. 2. Partisan role - allegation of acting on party lines (eg) - MCOCA was stopped while GUJCOCA was passed. 3. Agent of centre - as centre control appointment & removal process. 4. Head of universities - Kerala voicing against it. 5. Discretionary power misuse - seen in Arunachal (Nabik Rabia Case). 6. Reserving bill for President's assent and recommending President's rule. 7. Cases misused.
Significance
1. Uniquipuri of federalism - bridge between centre and state as it communicates between the two. 2. Centre's control over state's affair - duty under A.356 to ensure state acting in accordance with constitution. 3. Special role in tribal affairs - duty to ensure their welfare. 4. Strengthen federalism by acting in bona-fide manner.
Sali Sarabji said 'Governor can do great good if he is a good governor'.