Topper Copies

The doctrine of basic structure may be derived from the abstract. But it exists within the Constitution itself. Critically analyse.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

Constitution of India is a social contract, reflecting dreams \ ideals of founding fathers as well as general will of masses. These ideals are soul of constitution which need to be protected.

To preserve philosophy of Constitution, SC in Kesavanand Bharati Case 1973 propounded Basic Structure Doctrine.

This doctrine was proposed in the context of executive zeal to rewrite the constitution by amending it. In the era of majoritarian govt., SC protected constitution, saying any amendment can't harm the basic Structure of Constitution.

SC remarked that amendment should be such that we can trace original constitution. And Parliament only reflect popular will, not general will.

Basic Structure doctrine exist within constitution indirectly. Article 13 of constitution protect Rights from state's amendment. It enable SC to declare such laws as null & void.

Judicial review of SC also enables it to check constitutionality of executive and legislative actions. A.32 and other powers of SC is in conformity to Basic Structure Doctrine. Preamble also declare Indian State's features which can't be amended.

Critics argue that it was nowhere in constitution and it's an example of Judicial overreach. It was unprecedented as no other SC is as much powerful to criticise amendments. Judiciary is least accountable and representative → it harms parliamentary sovereignty.

But as Lia Madly pointed out, with this doctrine, India choose uncertain democracy over certain dictatorship.