Topper Copies

India has become an experiment where the two philosophies, Socialism and Capitalism, go together in concentric circles. Examine the statement in light of the term 'socialist' inserted in the Preamble of the Indian Constitution.

Astha Jain, AIR 9, 2025

Socialism refers to the ideology inspired by marx's idea that everyone in the society must have ownership to products of Society. It's an egalitarian philosophy aiming to give equality and life of dignity.

On other hand, Capitalism denotes profit-maximisation approach, the mode of production which creates 'haves' & 'have-not' based on locke's idea of right to property.

They both are seen as antagonist to eachother because one is based on 'equality of opportunity' (liberals) while socialist believe in equal outcomes. The capitalism is philosophy of bourgeois while socialism is proletariat. Their conception of man, society, rights etc. also differ.

But in India, these two theories are co-existing and integrated to suit Indian circumstances. Nehruvian socialism as enshrined in Preamble is based on Democratic Socialism.

Socialism in India's policy making denotes 'pro-poor' approach and emancipation of weaker sections. Nehru aimed at State-led approach to economic development whereby major Industries are controlled by States to control concentration of wealth and provide basic goods to masses.

At the same time, capitalism was allowed in certain sectors. Gradually, perils of Nehruvian approach was realised - crony capitalism, red tapism, poor growth, inflation etc.

So, in 1991 economic reforms (LPG) were introduced but still socialism & capitalism co-exist. State rebalanced these two and allowed both to thrive. Capitalism is promoted by State in economy - FDI, privatisation, disinvestment.

At the same time, state continue socialistic policies for poor sections - NREGA, Garib Kalyan Yojana, PM Awas, Ayushman Bharat etc.

This delicate balance is maintained to realise DPSP's ideal of minimising inequalities (A 38) and participation of workers in management of industries.

This experiment often face criticism due to tilt of state to one - Nehru towards Socialism, Modi towards capitalism. Also, habermas's crisis of legitimacy reflect dichotomy of welfare state.

Indian model is based on its need & circumstances & continue to evolve over time.