Discuss the class approach and economic determinism of the Marxist historians about the Indian freedom struggle. (10 Marks)
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Marxist approach to study Indian National Movement as one of the 'meta-narratives' to analyse the nature of movement.
Marxist historians like R.P. Dutt focused on class approach and economic determinism about the Indian freedom struggle.
M.N. Roy held INC to be a "Bourgeoise party" & Gandhi as a "Bourgeoise leader". R.P. Dutt called Gandhi as "Mascot of Bourgeoise". A.R. Desai held that the program of Gandhi and INC emerged out of historical needs of the bourgeoisie class".
S.N. Mukherjee criticised the reduction to class analysis and economic determinism. he held that INM was a complex movement with multiple sections & multiple strands of thought, and we cannot ignore factors like class
Subaltern scholars like Sumit Sarkar and Bipan Chandra highlight the role of peasant, working class, women movements. Sumit Sarkar held that INM was a very complicated idea with huge overlapping. They criticised National historians & Marxist historians for taking one sided view of INM.
Bipan Chandra summed up in his opinion that Indian struggle was a multi-class, multi-sect, multi-sect, and multi-religious movement encompassing all sections of society making it the largest mass movement of history